When you’re involved in a car accident, dealing with the insurance company can be overwhelming — especially when your claim is undervalued or denied. That’s where an auto insurance attorney comes in. These legal professionals specialize in helping accident victims get fair compensation from insurers across the United States.
In this comprehensive 2025 guide, you’ll learn what auto insurance attorneys do, when to hire one, how much they cost, and which top U.S. lawyers and law firms can help you win your claim fast.
What Does an Auto Insurance Attorney Do?
An auto insurance attorney represents clients in disputes involving car insurance claims — whether it’s coverage denial, bad faith practices, or low settlement offers. Their main roles include:
- Negotiating with insurers for fair settlements
- Filing lawsuits against insurance companies acting in bad faith
- Reviewing policy terms and identifying coverage loopholes
- Representing clients in court or arbitration
Auto insurance lawyers work closely with accident victims, especially when insurance companies delay or deny rightful claims.
When Do You Need an Auto Insurance Attorney?
You should hire a lawyer if:
- Your insurance claim was wrongfully denied or delayed
- You suffered serious injuries or financial losses
- The insurer offered an unfairly low settlement
- You’re accused of causing the accident but believe you’re not at fault
- You’re facing a complex multi-vehicle or commercial claim
In most states, insurers must act in good faith, but when they don’t, an attorney ensures you get what you deserve.
Top Auto Insurance Attorneys and Law Firms in the USA (2025 Edition)
Here are some of the most reputable law firms and attorneys across the U.S. specializing in car insurance disputes, personal injury, and accident claims.
1. Morgan & Morgan – Nationwide Coverage
- Website: www.forthepeople.com
- About: America’s largest injury law firm with offices in all 50 states. Their auto insurance division handles claim denials, underpayment cases, and wrongful claim rejections.
2. The Cochran Firm
- Website: www.cochranfirm.com
- About: Known for landmark settlements, The Cochran Firm’s attorneys specialize in motor vehicle insurance disputes and personal injury representation.
3. Levin Papantonio Rafferty (LPR)
- Website: www.levinlaw.com
- About: Based in Pensacola, Florida, LPR represents thousands of clients nationwide in auto and insurance-related claims, winning billions in settlements.
4. Cellino Law
- Website: www.cellinolaw.com
- About: A top-rated New York–based firm focusing on car accident and auto insurance litigation. They are known for aggressive negotiation tactics and high settlement rates.
5. Florin|Roebig Trial Attorneys
- Website: www.florinroebig.com
- About: Headquartered in Florida but operating nationwide, they’re recognized for excellence in motor vehicle insurance cases and multi-million-dollar jury verdicts.
6. Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro LLP
- Website: www.hbsslaw.com
- About: A national litigation firm handling auto insurance class actions, unfair claim denial cases, and large-scale policyholder protection lawsuits.
7. Wilshire Law Firm
- Website: www.wilshirelawfirm.com
- About: Based in California, Wilshire Law Firm has won over $1 billion for car accident victims and insurance dispute cases across the U.S.
How Much Does It Cost to Hire an Auto Insurance Lawyer?
Most auto insurance attorneys work on a contingency fee basis — meaning they get paid only if you win.
Typical fees range from:
- 25%–40% of the settlement amount
- $200–$500/hour for consultation-only services
Many firms offer free initial case reviews and charge nothing upfront.
How to Choose the Right Auto Insurance Attorney
- Check specialization: Ensure they handle car insurance disputes, not just personal injury cases.
- Review client testimonials: Look for verified Google and Avvo reviews.
- Confirm licensing: Verify their active bar status in your state.
- Ask about fees upfront: Get clear written terms before signing.
- Evaluate responsiveness: Choose attorneys who keep you updated regularly.
How to File a Car Insurance Dispute Claim
- Gather all evidence – Accident reports, photos, witness statements, and repair bills.
- Notify your insurance company – Submit a written claim request.
- Consult an auto insurance attorney – Get legal guidance before accepting a settlement.
- File a complaint – If denied, your attorney can file with the state insurance regulator.
- Litigation (if necessary) – The lawyer can sue for bad faith or breach of contract.
Common Bad Faith Insurance Tactics to Watch For
- Delaying your claim without valid reason
- Denying coverage without investigation
- Misrepresenting policy terms
- Offering unreasonably low settlements
- Ignoring evidence of liability
If you experience any of these, contact an attorney immediately — it could be grounds for a bad faith insurance lawsuit.
📚 You May Also Like
💡 Finding the Right Auto Insurance Attorney in Texas
Learn which Texas-based attorneys provide the strongest legal representation and highest claim success rates this year.
🚗Finding an Auto Insurance Attorney in Dallas
Explore top-rated Dallas attorneys helping victims maximize compensation for vehicle damage and medical expenses.
⚖️Auto Insurance Attorney in Philadelphia – 2025 Legal Help, Best Lawyers, and Claim Guide
Discover the pros and cons of managing your car insurance claim independently versus hiring a legal expert.
🔥Finding the Right Auto Insurance Attorney in California
See how California ranks and what factors drive up insurance rates across the country.